when you are a leader can u TK

[titanpilot321]

could you teamkill people for not following orders or retreating, I mean I hope it wouldn't be used for the wrong thing or overused, but it would be realistic if it was used when only necessary

[Leifr]

I can only ask, why do you think it's realistic?/
Military executions were incredibly rare for the period, even for deserters. I'm not sure why you feel it's necessary therefore to be able to 'TK' players.

[Gokiller]

Going to side with Leifr here. There is no reason to teamkill. However though. I do think there should be alternatives to enforce the rules within a regiment when on a server/event.

[Cynfar]

Teamkill should be part of the game. It should be a risk to randomly shoot around, or into covered areas, like a cornfield.

[Leifr]

That wasn't what he proposed Cynfar, read again.

[Arkansan]

The admins should have to ability to turn tk on or off on their own server. Then people can play whatever server they like and the community can handle the rest.

[Bravescot]

No TK should just be on permanently. Shoot your own men if you want, that's your own choice and a waste of your ticket pool

[A. P. Hill]

could you teamkill people for not following orders or retreating, I mean I hope it wouldn't be used for the wrong thing or overused, but it would be realistic if it was used when only necessary

Just a completely stupid idea.

If you have a problem recruit, you disband him and kick him out of your organization. Don't let him back in.

[-Mitchell-]

No TK should just be on permanently. Shoot your own men if you want, that's your own choice and a waste of your ticket pool

Agreed, it should be on permanently.

[reveal10]

no I do not think a commanding officer should in this scale of game be able to execute soldiers on the field. I do not think that this will be used properly in game and I think that it will be debated in game when it happens, which will only bog down the game with needless arguments

[VictorFernandes]

titanpilot321, from Australia...check.

Already set the reminder to not play with you ;)

[Wilson]

II think he was referring to how some officers in MB shoot members out of turn, such as when a recruit goes a wrong unit or says something that makes officer irritated, you see officers shoot people in the all the time. From a period of veiw no, however I myself had to deal with a rowdy member and do what was nesscary

[titanpilot321]

I agree, what was I thinking, in the end it would turn into an argument

[GreyDog58]

*cough* Court-martial *cough*

[MrAmerican]

realism? Yes TK should be a thing...

now this does allow for a lot of trolling, example: a troll company just firing into your flank for the hell of it during an event.

last thing we want is the teamkilling shit show that goes on before every event in Napoleonic Wars.

but to keep it realistic I do support teamkilling, because it did happen.
Just look at "Stonewall Jackson"

[BloodBeag]

There could be a limit on how many teamkills a company is allowed before possibly all being slayed with an extra long respawn timer or maybe just kick them off the server. I know you can easily make mistakes but it is sort of realistic that a group of soldiers would be taken out of battle if they couldn't be trusted to shoot only their enemies

[A. P. Hill]

because it did happen. Just look at "Stonewall Jackson"

What happened to Gen'l Jackson wasn't so much "teamkill" as it was an accident of circumstances.

The same as any other blue on blue "friendly" fire.

I'm all for keeping the efforts of the developers as realistic as possible, so let's not call it "teamkill" let's call it realistic circumstances. You aim a gun at any living thing and pull the trigger, as long as the weapon is loaded properly, you're going to injure that living thing.

If you think you have to shoot a member of your team on purpose, I suggest you seriously check your anger management and maturity.

And just remember, friendly fire isn't friendly.

[zimmer1lb]

I've been TKd before with no reason to it. All it did was pi** me off and seriously thought of revenge. It becomes, IMHO, a morale issue for the individual if not the community to have a device that can create an uncontrollable circumstance seemingly justified or not. Realistic or not. It is still a game and certain things, again IMHO, should not be entertained in a gaming community. Now being TKd because of vision/LOS impairment or something else would be different. I've TKd ppl, but totally by accident.


zimm out

[titanpilot321]

I've been TKd before with no reason to it. All it did was pi** me off and seriously thought of revenge. It becomes, IMHO, a morale issue for the individual if not the community to have a device that can create an uncontrollable circumstance seemingly justified or not. Realistic or not. It is still a game and certain things, again IMHO, should not be entertained in a gaming community. Now being TKd because of vision/LOS impairment or something else would be different. I've TKd ppl, but totally by accident.


zimm out

I agree, there was one game on red orchestra 2, where 1 person randomly TKed me and he said "i would say sorry but im not" he did this to more than just me so we ended up all TKing him back, so I agree that there should be a punishment for excessive and purposeful TKing

[Willie Fisterbottom]

I agree, there was one game on red orchestra 2, where 1 person randomly TKed me and he said "i would say sorry but im not" he did this to more than just me so we ended up all TKing him back, so I agree that there should be a punishment for excessive and purposeful TKing

Lol, you could always send them to the firing squad.

[Sorta]

Of course friendly fire should be in the game, and trolling should be managed by the administration of the server.